Theory X & Theory Y

In this lecture Prof. T Prasad discussed about 2 types of manger and employee, Type X and Type Y. The combination can be explained through below table.

Manager Type	Employee Type	Condition Description
X	X	Employee is lazy and manager thinks that employee is lazy.
X	Y	Employee is good but manager think employee is lazy.
Y	X	Employee is lazy but manager think employee is good.
Y	Y	Employee is good and manager think employee is good.

Condition 1:- Employee is lazy and Manager assumes that employee is lazy. This is a condition where both effectiveness and efficiency is compromised. Manager doesn’t motivate employee or try to find the ways to improve employee’s productivity. This condition is degenerative for Organization. We can see this scenario in lot of govt. organizations and this has been major reason for low productivity among them.

Condition 2:- Employee is good but manager think employee is lazy.This condition is also not good. Employee is trying to do his best but he is getting no incentive for that. Manager is not providing proper appreciation and motivation to employee. This results in deteriorating performance by employee, inclining the organization to move towards Condition 1.

Condition 3:- Employee is lazy but manager still treat him like a good employee. He provides proper motivation and feed back to employee, which results in better performance by employee, inclining the organization to move towards Condition 2.This is like Pygmalion phenomenon. ‘Things happen when they are expected’. I have seen similar cases in my company where my manager believed in every employee having some positive quality and that’s the reason they are working in the organization. He provided employee full flexibility to work in the part of the project they were interested in. he also encouraged employee to inculcate other leadership activities via courses facilitated by him and giving employee chance to work in manager’s shoe.

Condition 4:- This is condition for very effective and efficient organization. Employee is good and he is getting proper motivation to strive for better. I had similar experience in my previous organization, where I saw many employee including me transforming in a better person and employee with the help of guidance provided by my manager.

The major learning is that if Manager is of type Y, Organization is bound to move towards excellence irrespective of employee being X or Y type. Though, if employee is of type Y, transition is faster.